All the Sugar Cookie-Flavored Treats That Taste Just Like Christmas


Trending Now


Yum! The oven is on and the holiday sugar cookies are baking. Whoa. Wait a minute…the oven isn’t on. But you can still smell that sweet, sweet goodness of sugar-coated dough. What’s going on?

Forget about the real deal. This holiday season is filled with imaginatively awesome culinary creations that taste just like sugar cookies! And you won’t want to miss a single one of these. Seriously. They’re absolutely everything you’d imagine and our mouths are already watering.


Market Pantry Sugar Cookie Milk

Milk and cookies? Oh no, not with this genius creation. Target has sugar cookies. And they have milk. But for the holiday season they also have a sugar cookie-flavored milk (for $2.49). If you’re totally into this flavored milk, check out Market Pantry’s maple Pecan and Chocolate Mint milk too. 

Blue Bell

Blue Bell Christmas Cookie Ice Cream

If a snickerdoodle and a sugar cookie got together and had an ice cream dream child..well, Blue Bell’s super-delicious Christmas ice cream is it! Um, but that’s not all. Along with the cookie-flavored goodness, this ice cream adventure also includes red sprinkles and a green icing (yes, icing!) swirl. Mmm. We can taste the holiday happiness, 


Sugar Cookie Toast Crunch

How much do you love Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal? Now imagine a version that tastes just like little square sugar cookies. This limited edition breakfast bounty is a can’t-miss holiday pick. Seriously. If your first box lasts more than one day, you have way more self-control than the rest of us. You can pick this Christmas-y cereal up at most major grocery retailers for under $3!


Angie’s Boom Chicka Pop Frosted Sugar Cookie Flavored Kettle Corn

As if kettle corn isn’t amazing enough on its own (come on, combining sweet and salty is absolutely genius), now you can get it in sugar cookie flavor. Oh, and this sugar cookie weighs in a 110 calorie per cup. In other words, a handful won’t totally ruin your pre-holiday diet. Find this seasonal popcorn treat at major grocery retailers across the country. 

Wild Friends

Wild Friends Sugar Cookie Peanut Butter

Why would you ever make a regular ol’ PB&J when you could peanut butter the bread with a sugar cookie version? Yep, Wild Friends has created a peanut butter that captures the essence of your fave holiday cookies. Yay! And bonus, it only has five grams of sugar per serving. If you don’t want to run out of this cookie butter bliss, shop Wild Friends’ website and get a three-pack of 16oz. jars for $20.99.

—Erica Loop

Featured photo: Rawpixel



So Sip These Skinnier Versions of Your Fave Holiday Drinks Instead

2018 Black Friday Deals on Toys, Kids Clothes, Baby Gear & More

26 Amazing Advent Calendars You Need in Your Life

2018’s Top Gifts for Every Age, Stage & Interest

35 Insanely Popular Holiday Cookie Recipes

Welcome to our Tinybeans family!
Be sure to check your email for new activities, recipes and parenting hacks – and to see if you’ve won!








Enter to Win a $250 Gift Card!

Enter your email and zip code below for a chance to win a Mastercard Gift Card. We’ll pick one winner per month through October 31, 2022 – 7 lucky winners in all!

I agree to the official rules and to receive email communications from Tinybeans. By providing my email address, I agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.