Site icon Tinybeans

Shop Boston’s Best Toy Stores for Unique Gifts

a girl hugs a light brown teddy bear in front of a pink background from a toy store in Boston

Get a jumpstart on your holiday shopping at our favorite toy stores in Boston. Hint: They have great gift recs

The holiday countdown has begun! We know for many parents that means thinking about finding that perfect gift for family and friends, even while driving around to see holiday lights and heading out to find your tree. Sure, it’s always easy to shop online, local toy stores in Boston have some of the coolest gifts for kids in town. With everything from personalized recommendations to gorgeous gift wrapping and free local delivery, these independent toy stores make holiday shopping a breeze. Here’s where to shop small this year.

1. The Blue Bunny Books & Toys

This "little shop with a big mission" was opened back in 2003 by children's book author, Peter H. Reynolds, the brilliant mind behind The Dot. The large blue bunny outside welcomes kids into the cozy shop that's not only got a great selection of toys, but books as well. As you can imagine, the authors who "hop" into the shop for book signings and readings are some of the best around. Find all sorts of unusual and interesting toys for everyone on your list (no matter what the occasion) when you stop in this store in Dedham.

Insider Tip: Gift wrapping is always free at this friendly store.

577 High St.
Dedham, MA
Online: bluebunnybooks.com

Related: The Best New Children's Books of 2022 (So Far)

2. CouCou

Let's just say you'd have to be crazy not to shop here. CouCou (pronounced “koo-koo”) is the French word used for the globally popular children’s game of Peek-a-boo. The store, located in the South End neighborhood of Boston, Massachusetts, offers a wide selection of uniquely curated products for ages 0-10, including clothes, toys, crafts, homewares and gifts, imported from around the globe.

24 Union Park St.
Boston
Online: coucou-boston.com

3. Magpie Kids

Featuring shiny new things to spruce up your kiddo’s nest, Magpie Kids focuses on modern toys. It’s where you’ll find locally made toys, as well clothing and gift items from recognizable brands like Milkbarn, Angel Dear, and Plan Toys. Stop in to find that just-right gift, whether you're shopping for baby's arrival, baby's first birthday, or any other memorable milestones for your kids. Whatever they're into—arts and crafts, playing music, reading, or just making believe—they've got what you need here.

46 White St.
Somerville, MA
Online: magpiekids.com

Related: 15 Incredible Gifts for a Three-Year-Old

4. The Happy Journey

One of Boston's newer toy stores on the block, The Happy Journey was opened not too long ago by Lindsay Perrelli, an elementary school teacher and children's author. It’s everyone’s go-to spot for educational, high-quality toys, books, and games that Perrelli has personally selected. Stop by each season to browse the skillfully built displays that are as appealing to parents as they are to kids. 

73 Charles St.
Boston
Online: instagram.com/thehappyjourneytoys

5. Henry Bear's Park

With eight Boston-area locations to choose from, you'll definitely find what you need at this super-cool toy store. Shop their online store where you can find gifts sorted by age and interest, as well as some super fun options like personalized surprise packs. With free shipping on orders over $50 and free gift wrap, this is a great option for those who want to check gift buying off their list, but haven't quite gotten around to it yet this year.

Find your nearest location here

Online: henrybear.com

6. Magic Beans

You can get tons of toys plus all the essential baby gear you need all under one roof at Magic Beans. They've been around since 2004, so they're totally up on all the hot toys and new products that you need. And did we mention they're parents, too? Takes one to know one when it comes to finding gifts and products your kids will actually use.

361 Huron Ave.
Cambridge, MA

200 Linden St.
Wellesley, MA

Online: mbeans.com

Related: 14 Unique Gifts for Two-Year-Olds

7. Boing! Toy Shop

This toy shop is a community favorite and has called Jamaica Plain home for over 20 years. It is run by a local mom who is focused on building community and giving back. Don't worry—she also loves stocking the shelves with the coolest toys around. The oversized Alien Boingers that are hanging around outside the store set the tone for your shopping experience here. It's all about fun and finding that just-right toy, book, or game that will be played with time and time again. 

Good to Know: There's free local deliveries of orders over $50 and free shipping on orders over $75. 

Insider Tip: We can't get enough of the Boing's Kindness Club that encourage kids to perform random acts of kindness in their community for a small prize.

667 Centre St.
Jamaica Plain, MA
Online: boingtoys.com

8. Eureka! Puzzles

This toy store right in the heart of Coolidge Corner focuses on puzzles, board games, brain teasers, and STEM gifts for kids of all ages. Make shopping for kids easy on everyone in the family (we're looking at your grandparents) when you create a wish list for your kids. It's the best gift to give those who are doing the shopping. And if you're looking for something a little different to give this year? Why not try a personalized puzzle on Eureka's new puzzle press

1355 Beacon St.
Brookline, MA
Online: eurekapuzzles.com

9. Tadpole

Parents-to-be know that Tadpole is the place to go for baby registries and all the gear you'll need to bring the little one home. They also have a ton of unique gifts for kids like including STEM toys, LEGO sets, puzzles, and more. It's a great spot to shop for the toddler in your life.

58 Clarendon St.
Boston
Online: shoptadpole.com