Easter baskets can be absolutely adorable… until they’re 90% sugar and 10% things your kid forgets about by noon. If you’re looking to skip the candy overload (or just balance it out a little, because it’s hard to resist a chocolate bunny), these Easter basket fillers bring the fun without the inevitable sugar crash. Think small surprises, actually-useful finds, and a few “wait, this is genius” picks that’ll last longer than the weekend.
We only recommend what we’ve independently researched, selected, and genuinely love. If you make a purchase through our links, we may earn a commission (at no extra cost to you).
Baby’s basket
Mon Ami Just Hatched Plush Basket
A plush toy, but with main character Easter energy. Soft, sweet, and perfectly on-theme for Easter, this is the kind of keepsake that sticks around long after the basket is dismantled.
Mon Ami Just Hatched Plush Basket ($54) — Buy here
mushie Baby Bunny Teether
Equal parts adorable and actually useful, this soft silicone teether is easy for tiny hands to grab and gentle on sore gums. Plus, Amazon reviewers rated it 4.8 stars, so this one is truly a win. Bonus: it looks cute enough to leave out instead of immediately hiding in a drawer.
mushie Baby Bunny Teether ($12.99) — Buy here
What's Poppin Corn Spinner
A classic cause-and-effect toy with a very cute glow-up. Baby presses, things pop and spin, and suddenly you’ve bought yourself a few moments to get into the deviled eggs. Everyone wins.
What's Poppin Corn Spinner ($16.97) — Buy here
Pantone: Box of Color Board Book Set
A baby book, but make it design-forward. This set of six mini board books introduces little ones to color through bold Pantone shades and simple visuals that are just as satisfying for you as they are for them. It’s giving future creative director energy.
Pantone: Box of Color Board Book Set ($13.99) — Buy here
Montessori Egg Stacking Toy
Stacking toys are a baby basket staple, but this one leans into the Easter theme without being cheesy. It helps with coordination, problem-solving, and keeping little hands busy in a way that feels intentional.
Montessori Egg Stacking Toy ($11.98) — Buy here
Tulip Roly Poly Plush
This wobbly little toy is basically baby entertainment magic. A sweet plush with lots of grab-friendly places helps build motor skills while keeping their attention longer than… most things.
Tulip Roly Poly Plush ($44) — Buy here
Basket picks for toddlers
Play-Doh Easter Eggs Bag
The Easter version of a forever favorite. These pre-filled eggs are basically ready-made basket fillers that guarantee a lot of focused (and creative) play.
Play-Doh Easter Eggs Bag ($9.99) — Buy here
Fairy Garden Plate & Utensils
Magical meals incoming. This whimsical set turns everyday bites into a tiny fairy-approved experience, which, honestly, might be a huge advantage during a “I don’t like this” spiral.
Fairy Garden Plate & Utensils ($36) — Buy here
Honeysticks Super Jumbo Bath Crayons
Bathtime + a mini art studio. These chunky, easy-to-hold crayons are made for little hands and wash off easily, so they can go full Picasso without any lingering mess.
Honeysticks Super Jumbo Bath Crayons ($19.95) — Buy here
Hide-and-Seek Bunnies with Carrot Pouch
A plush toy and a built-in activity? Say less. Toddlers can tuck the tiny bunnies in and out of their carrot home on repeat, which is exactly the kind of simple, satisfying play you can't go wrong with.
Hide-and-Seek Bunnies with Carrot Pouch ($20.79) — Buy here
Melissa & Doug Forest Friends Puzzle
A classic puzzle with a sensory twist. Different textures keep little hands engaged while helping build fine motor skills, making this one feel both fun and sneakily educational.
Melissa & Doug Forest Friends Puzzle ($15.99) — Buy here
Bluey Aqua Art
Coloring with zero mess? A parenting win if we’ve ever seen one. Just add water and watch the colors appear, then disappear again when it dries, so they can do it all over (and over, and over).
Bluey Aqua Art ($4.99) — Buy here
cuddle+kind Baby Animal Collection
A plush with a little more heart behind it. These soft, beautifully made dolls are the kind of keepsake gift that feels extra special — and yes, they’re just as cuddle-worthy as they look. You can also pick three favorites (tricky, we know) and create a little animal cottage gift that we've definitely been squealing over.
cuddle+kind Baby Animal Collection ($43) — Buy here
Vintage Toddler Sunglasses 2pk
Tiny sunglasses = tiny Ferris Bueller vibes (in a good way). They’re practical, adorable, and make even a grocery store run feel like a full outfit moment.
Vintage Toddler Sunglasses 2pk ($7.99) — Buy here
Counting Carrots Stacker
Bright, playful, and just structured enough to feel like learning. This counting set helps build early math skills while still feeling like a game, not just a lesson.
Counting Carrots Stacker ($29.99) — Buy here
Melissa & Doug Sticker WOW! Bunny Bundle
Stickers, but with a twist. This stamp-style set delivers just enough novelty to keep toddlers engaged without leaving your entire house covered in adhesive surprises.
Melissa & Doug Sticker WOW! Bunny Bundle ($9.48) — Buy here
Toddler Work Gloves 2pk
For the toddler who insists on “helping.” Whether they’re digging in the dirt or just vibing in the backyard (as toddlers do), these make them feel involved (and keep their hands cleaner in the process). Bonus: you can snag a matching mom pair here.
Toddler Work Gloves 2pk ($13.99) — Buy here
Peter Rabbit Shape Sorter
A nostalgic classic with a toddler-friendly twist. It’s colorful, interactive, and perfect for building those early problem-solving skills (with a little Beatrix Potter charm baked in). It's basically art and a toy.
Peter Rabbit Shape Sorter ($16.97) — Buy here
Ice Cream Sand Toys
"Sand-friendly ice cream" actually sounds like something a toddler would invent. These soft silicone molds are perfect for outdoor play and easy to clean, which is exactly the kind of low-effort win we’re after.
Ice Cream Sand Toys ($19.99) — Buy here
Let The Beet Drop DJ Set
Yes, your toddler is now a DJ, and no, we couldn't help ourselves. Lights, sounds, buttons — this one is pure sensory fun and will absolutely become a daily concert.
Let The Beet Drop DJ Set ($33.94) — Buy here
Easter ideas for younger kids
OOLY x Girl Scouts Cookie-Scented Gel Pens
Dessert-coded school supplies are our new favorite trend. These scented gel pens smell like classic Girl Scout cookies, which somehow makes homework feel closer to fun.
OOLY x Girl Scouts Cookie-Scented Gel Pens ($5.95) — Buy here
Kids Instant Digital Camera
For the kid who’s already documenting their life like a tiny influencer. This instant camera lets them snap photos, print memories, and fully lean into their artistic side.
Kids Instant Digital Camera ($33.99) — Buy here
Roll of the Dice: Enchanted Forest Adventure Book
Part book, part game, all imagination. Kids roll the dice to shape the story as they go, making every read-through a little different (and way more engaging).
Roll of the Dice: Enchanted Forest Adventure Book ($21.82) — Buy here
Floral Tumbling Tower Game
A classic game with a pretty little upgrade. It’s easy to learn, fun for all ages, and one of those rare picks that might even get the whole family involved.
Floral Tumbling Tower Game ($19.99) — Buy here
Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty
This oddly satisfying putty is perfect for fidgeting, stretching, and keeping busy hands occupied in the most low-key way possible.
Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty ($14.99) — Buy here
Kinetic Sand Surprise Wild Critters
Messy in theory, but surprisingly manageable in practice. This sensory set delivers that satisfying, squishy play kids love (without completely wrecking your floors).
Kinetic Sand Surprise Wild Critters ($3.99) — Buy here
Magna-Tiles Spring Garden Set
A fan-favorite for a reason. These colorful magnetic tiles encourage creative builds and actually grow with your kid, making them one of those toys that stick around.
Magna-Tiles Spring Garden Set ($19.97) — Buy here
Hatchimals Alive Spring Basket
If you want a guaranteed reaction, this is it. There’s something about the surprise + unboxing moment that just nails it every time.
Hatchimals Alive Spring Basket ($18.97) — Buy here
Mudpuppy Springtime Parade Puzzle
A sweet, colorful puzzle that’s just challenging enough to keep them focused. Bonus: it’s cute enough to leave out without ruining your aesthetic.
Mudpuppy Springtime Parade Puzzle ($9.95) — Buy here
Olive the Cat Toy Pet
All the joy of a pet, none of the responsibility. Olive even comes in her own little purse, so she's equal parts feline and fashionista.
Olive the Cat Toy Pet ($14.99) — Buy here
Sarah’s Silks Mystery Egg
A little bit of magic in egg form. Each one hides a surprise wooden animal inside, making it feel like a keepsake instead of a one-and-done toy.
Sarah’s Silks Mystery Egg ($18) — Buy here
Hazel Hen Crossbody Purse
A tiny bag for their very important belongings (rocks, stickers, mystery crumbs). It’s cute, functional, and immediately becomes part of the daily outfit rotation.
Hazel Hen Crossbody Purse ($44) — Buy here
Bunny Night Light
Equal parts squishy, color-changing decor and comfort. This soft-glow bunny lamp adds a cozy touch to their room and makes bedtime feel pretty darn cute.
Bunny Night Light ($18.99) — Buy here
For the big kids (who still love a basket)
Touchland Hydrating Hand Sanitizer Spray 3pk
Aesthetic hand sanitizer has been having a moment for... a while now. These sleek sprays smell amazing, feel good on your hands, and somehow make basic hygiene feel like a lifestyle choice.
Touchland Hydrating Hand Sanitizer Spray 3pk ($30) — Buy here
Foosbots Tabletop Trick Shot Game
Small but mighty (friendly) competitive energy. This tabletop game is easy to pick up, weirdly addictive, and perfect for kids who love a little challenge.
Foosbots Tabletop Trick Shot Game ($22.95) — Buy here
Plant the Box Watermelon Candle
A candle… but with a plot twist. Once it’s done, you can plant the box and grow wildflowers, making this feel equal parts cozy and unexpectedly cool. *Best for older kids with adult supervision.
Plant the Box Watermelon Candle ($34) — Buy here
Preloaded Retro Video Game Player
Old-school games, new-school obsession. This handheld is packed with 220 nostalgic classics that are just as fun now as they were back then.
Preloaded Retro Video Game Player ($37.99) — Buy here
Magic 8 Ball x MoMA Edition
A magical classic turned ultra-cool art. This upgraded version feels a little more design-forward while still delivering nine custom phrases (far more helpful than the original, tbh).
Magic 8 Ball x MoMA Edition ($35) — Buy here
Thames & Kosmos SolarFlower
Part science, part window decor, part “wait, this is actually cool.” Powered by sunlight, this little buildable project sneaks in learning without feeling like homework.
Thames & Kosmos SolarFlower ($24.95) — Buy here
3D Printed Dragon Egg
No one can get enough of these mysterious, textured, tiny-dragon-inside eggs. It’s the kind of gift that immediately becomes their favorite thing (and ours, actually) for no logical reason.
3D Printed Dragon Egg ($12.99) — Buy here
NeeDoh Dippin’ Dazzler
A stress egg that squishes, stretches, and changes color in water, making it perfect for kids who always need something in their hands.
NeeDoh Dippin’ Dazzler ($4.97) — Buy here
Nerf Vortex Aero Howler
Loud? Yes. Fun? Also yes. This high-flying football whistles as it soars, which is either the best part or the worst part, depending on your perspective.
Nerf Vortex Aero Howler ($14.99) — Buy here
