29 Unique Easter Basket Fillers (That Aren’t Candy)

easter basket fillers, easter basket stuffers

These Easter basket stuffers are as sweet as the inevitable chocolate Easter bunny

If there’s one thing the Easter Bunny (ahem, you) knows, it’s that there are plenty of treats floating around on the big day. That’s why a basket not brimming with sugar is a good move for you and the kids. They’ll have fun surprises to enjoy, and you’ll be spared the inevitable crash after one too many chocolate bunnies. We’ve curated a unique collection of Easter basket fillers for kids of all ages, even hard-to-please tweens.

LEGO Easter Rabbit Set

LEGO Easter basket fillers

The new Easter LEGO set of two bunnies amongst the tulips and Easter eggs will keep the kids busy while you get things ready for your Easter brunch or lunch

Ages: 8+

Buy it here, $13

Easter Mad Libs

Easter mad libs

Mad Libs are fun for everyone, and this Easter-themed collection is perfect for keeping kids busy with their extended family on Easter Sunday. 

Ages: 5+

Buy it here, $6

Ducky's Fluffle Sidewalk Chalk

bunny sidewalk chalk as Easter basket stuffers

It's time to stock up on sidewalk chalk, and these bunnies are perfect Easter basket fillers. You'll get six pieces that fit perfectly into kids' hands and look a lot like Peeps!

Ages: 3+

Buy them here, $22

DIY Easter Bunny Necklace

For your creative kids, this DIY bunny necklace is a perfect fit! It comes with three markers and is the perfect project after the Easter egg hunt. 

Ages: 3+

Buy it here, $25

Easter Stampies

Easter stampies

While these are "technically" cookie stamps, we're envisioning hours of sensory fun using play dough, kinetic sand, and other sensory materials. The set includes six silicone molds in an Easter theme and one wooden stamper. 

Ages: 2+

Buy it here, $18

Nee Doh Gummy Bear Stress Ball

Nee Doh gummy bear stress ball for Easter basket filler

Who doesn't want to squeeze the heck out of a brightly colored gummy bear? They're each just 3.5" tall, and when you order one, you'll get either pink, blue, purple, or orange at random. 

Ages: 3+

Buy it here, $10

Fantastical Kids Easter Basket Fillers

Easter basket fillers from Uncommon Goods

If you don't have time to think about Easter basket stuffers, let Uncommon Goods do the work for you. This curated collection of unique gift items will please any curious kid. You'll get a tub of fantasy dough from Land of Dough, a zodiac notebook, pencils and a crystal growing kit, and a fun card game. 

Ages: 5+

Buy it here, $47

Bright Stripes Forest Festival

paper lantern is a cute Easter basket filler

Kids can create a beautiful 3D paper lantern that has a magical illustration of woodland creatures on the inside. The kit comes with an LED tea light, gems, stickers, and the sticky paper they'll need to put it together. 

Ages: 8+

Buy it here, $20

Froglet Umbrella

This adorable umbrella will protect them from April showers and keep them smiling with its fun illustrations. 

Ages: 4+

Buy it here, $13

 

JOYIN Vehicle Eggs

plastic eggs with toys inside

What a fun surprise for an Easter egg hunt or Easter basket! These toy-filled eggs can take the place of candy-filled eggs but the excitement level will be just as high. 

Ages: 3+

Buy them here, $11

Meri Meri Easter Coloring Poster

There are two posters in this sweet set: one of a bunny surrounded by flowers and one with classic Easter illustrations like eggs, chicks, bunnies, and carrots. 

Ages: 3+

Buy it here, $12

Just Dutch Miffy & Friends

Just Dutch Miffy bunny is a cute easter basket filler

She might be one of the cutest bunny rabbits—ever. Miffy and her friends Melanie and Boris are handmade crocheted soft toys, and you can choose from a wide assortment of outfits, ranging from overalls to dresses and even outfits inspired by famous painters (think Monet, Vermeer, and Van Gogh). The hardest part will be deciding which one to order. 

Ages: 2+

Buy them here, $37

Bloom & Kettle Zodiac Star Sign Soap

Zodiac soaps are fun Easter basket fillers for teens

Each of these soaps has a distinct scent and the wrapper displays the flower, crystal, color, and herb associated with each star sign. 

Ages: 10+

Buy them here, $12

Raffia Bunny Backpack

bunny backpack

Splurge on something they'll love long after the chocolate bunnies are gone. This woven backpack has plenty of room for treasures and is perfect for summer adventures. 

Ages: 3-4+

Buy it here, $55

WowWee Untamed Raptor

Untamed raptor from WowWee is a great Easter basket stuffer

This Easter basket stuffer is fun for dino lovers! These little guys roar, chomp, move their heads, and will react to sounds. 

Ages: 5+

Buy it here, $15

Scentco Spring Smencils

Easter basket stuffers

These scented pencils are the perfect Easter basket stuffers! They are made from recycled newspapers and come in fun scents like jelly bean, sour apple, cotton candy, and more. 

Ages: 5+ 

Buy them here, $9

Pollinator Garden Push Pops

seed bombs make good Easter basket filler

Each one of these adorable seed bombs contains enough seeds to plant a square-foot garden patch. Designed to attract pollinators like butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds, kids will have fun learning about and watching their efforts to help support food production thrive. 

Ages: 4+

Buy them here, $19

Eco Kids Finger Paint

finger paint for Easter basket stuffers

Kids can use finger paint before they can hold a paintbrush, and this collection from Eco Kids is as colorful as it is fun. Mix the paint with water (as much or as little as you need), give them paper, and let the creativity flow! Made from organic fruits and veggies, you can feel confident giving this to mouthy little ones. 

Ages: 3+

Buy it here, $19

Meri Meri Veggie Surprise Balls

Veggie Surprise balls for Easter basket fillers

Made to look like a Farmer's Market veggie crate, these surprise balls contain stickers, an eraser, a joke, a friendship bracelet, and a party hat. We love that you can use these as Easter basket fillers or use them to brighten up your holiday table. 

Ages: 3+

Buy them here, $28

My Bevi Retro Wave Insulated Cup

an insulated cup is a good Easter basket filler for tweens

This 12 oz. insulated stainless steel tumbler offered in seven different hues is perfect for tweens who want a "grown-up cup." They can use it for cold beverages, hot tea, or hot chocolate. The best part? They'll stop stealing yours. 

Ages: 10+ 

Buy it here, $20

Educational Insights Playfoam Spring & Easter Sets

Playfoam never dries out, comes in fun colors, and is a good sensory material for kids of all ages. These new sets come in pastels perfect for spring and Easter. 

Ages: 3+

Buy it here, $16

VTech Hatch and Roaaar Egg

Hatch and roaaar egg

There are four of mini Switch and Go eggs to choose from (T-Rex, Triceratops, Velociraptor, Pterodactyl), and they all transform from a dinosaur to a moving vehicle. They also roar, rumble, and light up at the touch of a button. 

Ages: 4+

Buy it here, $11

Tattly Tiny Butterfly Tattoo Tin

butterfly tattoos for easter basket fillers

This gorgeous collection of butterfly tattoos includes Tiger Moths, Black Swallowtails, and more. Made with vegetable-based ink, each one lasts for 2-4 days. 

Ages: 3+

Buy it here, $20

 

Give It a Swirl Tie-Dye Kit

tie-dye kit for tweens

Making tie-dye shirts is a rite of passage for tweens, and this easy-to-use kit has everything they need to get started. It even includes a drop cloth to catch spills. 

Ages: 10+ 

Buy it here, $10

Calico Critters Easter Celebration Set

Calico Critters easter basket fillers

This adorable set includes the exclusive Marguerite Rabbit Brother and Sister dressed in their Easter finest. There are mini eggs and miniature candy for an Easter egg hunt. 

Ages: 3+ 

Buy it here, $20

Left Center Right Dice Game

dice game as an Easter basket stuffer

For kids who aren't into the spring and Easter themes as much, mini-games like this one make great Easter basket fillers. It can be played just about anywhere and it's something they'll enjoy for years to come. 

Ages: 5+

Buy it here, $8

Ooly Chunkies Paint Sticks

ooly chunkies paint sticks for Easter basket stuffers

A favorite for little fingers, these chunky paint sticks are perfect for toddler Easter baskets. Easy to use, with little mess, there's a reason why these are so popular. 

Ages: 2-3+

Buy them here, $14

Gift Cards

gift cards for easter basket filler for teens

This might sound totally unoriginal, but your tween will be thrilled to find a gift card in their Easter basket. Make it a small denomination ($5, $10), and either go with one from their favorite store or restaurant or just give a general cash card! 

Ages: 10+ 

Buy one here, prices vary

Knockaround Pinata Party Sunglasses

sunglasses for Easter basket stuffers

Get the kids ready for sunny weather with a new pair of shades! This style is offered in tons of different colors and prints, and while they're a little more pricey than other sunglasses, they have UV400 sun protection and will last a lot longer. 

Ages: 5+

Buy them here, $25

If you buy something from the links in this article, we may earn affiliate commission or compensation.

Editor’s Note: At the time of publication all of the items above were in stock and available at the listed price.

Images courtesy of retailers. 

Group-1755-1.svg

Parenting news, advice, and inspo… right in your inbox.

By signing up to Tinybeans newsletters you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy