The Scoop: Where to Grab Ice Cream in Atlanta

kids eating ice cream in summer

Don’t let the heat get you all hot and bothered—scoop up some of the original Mother’s Little Helper and chill out, instead. From classic favorites at ice cream institutions to modern takes on the sweet stuff, Atlanta’s dripping with options. You’ll especially love the spot that has two kid favorites: trains and ice cream. 

Butter & Cream
All ice cream at this Decatur institution is hand-made right there in the store, with flavors ranging from classic to exotic—honey lavender fig and dark chocolate malbec, for starters—you might never leave. Check out their seasonally rotating menu for the most “now” flavors.

The Cherry On Top: Take your ice cream and stroll to the nearby Little Shop of Stories—they have story times on Tuesday, Thursday, and Sunday!

416 Church St.

661 Auburn Ave. Suite 130
Online: butterandcream.com

Cathy’s

You’ll find gourmet ice cream sandwiches at this treasure, where you begin by choosing your cookies (there are seven types to choose among), your ice cream (16 flavors that range from standard to exotic), and a topping which your sandwich is rolled in. While it’s not cheap—a cookie sandwich will run you a solid $10—each custom concoction is deliciously indulgent.

The Cherry On Top: Want to try making a gourmet ice cream sandwich at home? Cathy’s sells cookie kits with cookie dough ready to go and ice cream by the pint.

855 Peachtree Street
Online: cathyscle.com

 

Sub-Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream
This flash-frozen ice cream is created using liquid nitrogen. And the founders take the idea of science in the kitchen seriously—they even offer classroom demos and have a song about the Periodic Table on their homepage. Whatever the science behind this ice cream, it’s good.

The Cherry On Top: The downtown location is a perfect place to stop after a morning at the Children’s Museum or an afternoon at Centennial Olympic fountains.

250 Park Ave. W NW
Centennial Park District

11720 Medlock Bridge Rd.
Duluth
Online: subzeroicecream.com

Paolo’s Gelato
From the kid-level glass case displaying fluffy mountains of the good stuff to the wafer cookie on top of every scoop, this Va-Hi sweet shop will delight kids and adults alike. If you’re a stickler for the trifecta (chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry), you might be disappointed because the flavors change and trend towards Nutella, zabaione, rose, and amaretto. Don’t forget your cash as this joint doesn’t take cards.

The Cherry On Top: It’s a wafer cookie, not a cherry. But it’s yummy.

1025 Virginia Ave. NE
Online: paolosgelato.com

Queen of Cream
This homemade ice cream window in Inman Park starts its batches with local grass-fed dairy and makes small batches in-house using fresh and local ingredients. So pick up your scoop at the ice cream window located on Bernina.

The Cherry on Top: Vegan flavors, including Mango Coconut, hold their own on the menu.

337 Elizabeth St NE
Atlanta
Online: queenofcream.com

Jake’s Ice Cream
Jake’s Ice Cream can be found in many locations around town, but get it at the Irwin Street Market for the traditional ice cream parlor effect. Ice cream coolers straddle an old-fashioned ice cream bar with red vinyl stools and glistening countertops. For the wobblers out there, there are also family-style kitchen tables in a lounge adjacent to the ice cream counter. Jake’s impressive list of creative (and offbeat) flavors satisfies every craving in your crowd. They’re also opening a new location in East Point this summer, so keep an eye out.

The Cherry On Top: The ISM houses breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dessert vendors all under one roof, so hit this spot if you can’t bring yourself to make dinner… or lunch… or brunch… one day. It’s right off the Beltline and a worthy destination. Keep in mind that they’re only open on Sat. & Sun. from 2-5 p.m., so plan your day around it.

660 Irwin St.
Online: jakesicecream.com

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams
Think of this sweet spot as education for tiny tounges. Nestled in the hip Haute spot of the Westside Provisions District, this ice cream counter serves up samples of fanciful flavors like Wildberry Lavender, Goat Cheese & Red Cherries, and Riesling Poached Pear Sorbet.

The Cherry On Top: A waffle wedge comes complimentary with each scoop. Don’t forget to load up on pints to take home to bribe the babes later.

1198 Howell Mill Rd.

77 West Paces Ferry Rd., Suite 35B
Online: jenis.com

Frosty Caboose
Trains and treats? Yes, please. This sweet shop is a converted train caboose with a walk-up window serving Greenwood’s ice cream—Atlanta’s answer to Mayfield’s on a smaller scale and with wilder flavors. With a private and plentiful parking lot between the caboose and the actual train track (another plus for your little train aficionados), you can enjoy your ice cream tailgate-style or stroll the streets of downtown Chamblee as you eat.

The Cherry On Top: Can’t get enough of Greenwood Ice Cream? Check out their manufacturing location not far from The Frosty Caboose. You can score an ice cream cake from one of the coolers up front if you’re lucky!

5435 Peachtree Rd.
Online: frostycaboose.com

Morelli’s
This is ice cream the way it’s supposed to be. Morelli’s churns up traditional flavors (salted caramel will make you moan) and more creative combinations (think strawberry balsamic, maple bacon, or coconut jalapeño). But no matter your kids’ tastes, the creamy, smooth, rich quality of Morelli’s will have them begging for more.

The Cherry On Top: The Moreland Avenue store is a perfect stop after a day at the zoo.

749 Moreland Ave. SE,

4515 Chamblee Dunwoody Rd.
Online: morellisicecream.com

Kilwin’s
Okay, Kilwin’s is a chain, but there is only one in Georgia (in Atlantic Station), and you should go. The smell of chocolate greets guests at the door, and kids will marvel at the toys, candy cases, and decorations as they make their way back towards the ice cream. Very few things can distract a child from an ice cream cone, but the candy maker molding bite-sized chocolates at the front of the store might do it.

The Cherry On Top: They make their waffle cones in-house. Yum.

1380 Atlantic Dr. Suite 14160

251 Market St.
Alpharetta
Online: kilwins.com

RELATED STORIES:
5 High-Flying Zipline Adventures Near Atlanta
Atlanta’s Best Nearby RV Parks
The Spin: 9 Kid-Friendly Bike Paths Around Atlanta
15 Utterly Awesome Kids Bike Helmets + DIY Helmet Ideas

Welcome to our Tinybeans family!
Be sure to check your email for new activities, recipes and parenting hacks – and to see if you’ve won!

 

 

 

 

 

 

FALL FOR TINYBEANS!

Enter to Win a $250 Gift Card!

Enter your email and zip code below for a chance to win a Mastercard Gift Card. We’ll pick one winner per month through March 31, 2023 – 12 lucky winners in all!

I agree to the official rules and to receive email communications from Tinybeans. By providing my email address, I agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.