Chicago’s Best Chocolate Chip Cookies (Find Out Where They’re Hiding!)

Advertisement

Trending Now


Advertisement

“C” is for cookie. And if that isn’t enough to make your little monster’s tummy rumble, along come “CCC” — chocolate chip cookies! Chicago does the indulgence justice, because we have kid-friendly bakeries and restaurants that make delicious, from-scratch versions of the treats—from cookies as big as your head to infused deliciousness. You’re never far from your next fix. Here is where we get ours.

Beatrix

Beatrix is the Beyonce of restaurants. It does it all, from breakfast to lunch, brunch to dessert. One of the best ways for families to experience Beatrix is via its coffee and pastry bar, which is a full-fledged bakery inside the restaurant. The selection offers an overwhelming array of muffins, breads, cakes, scones and more. Something Beatrix does exceptionally well is cookies, particularly the chocolate chunk cookie. These large, saucer-sized indulgences achieve the perfect middle ground of crispy along the exterior and soft in the center. Each bite of this thick cookie gives way to a pleasant doughy chew, brimming with fudge-y melted chocolate.

5 locations in River North, Streeterville, Loop, Fulton Market & Oak Brook; Online: beatrixrestaurants.com

 

Big.Fat.Cookie

Big.Fat.Cookie makes chocolate chip cookies so delicious looking, it’s almost a shame to eat them. Almost. They are made in very small batches with an insane amount of attention to detail—they weigh each cookie and add individual chocolate chips to be sure they’re made to perfection. You can find them at retail stores throughout the city or place an order for pickup at their location on Hooker. Pick-up days are Wed.-Sat., 11 a.m.-4 p.m.

1030 N. Hooker St., Goose Island; Online: eatmebigfatcookie.com

 

Bake

A bakery that prides itself on classic American confections is bound to excel in the chocolate chip cookie department. Such is the case at Bake in Bucktown. This adorable, nostalgic Americana bakeshop peddles all the sweets that childhood dreams are made of, including exemplary chocolate chip cookies. Like the menu and motif at Bake, these cookies are pure classics, likely the closest you’ll come to mom-made cookies in Chicago, rich with notes of butter, sugar and smooth chocolate morsels.

2246 W. North Ave., Bucktown; Online: bakechicago.com

Carol’s Cookies

Oh Carol, you temptress. Based in Highland Park, Carol’s Cookies has gotten a cult following for its football-sized cookies. (We’re exaggerating a bit on the size—but barely.) With a big shipping business and wholesale business, Carol’s Cookies are not hard to come by, making it all too easy to binge on sugar and ruin appetites for dinner. The brown sugary chocolate chip cookies are the embodiment of indulgence, not only in sheer heft, but in the astounding richness compacted into every single nook and cranny.

Check website for retail locations & order online at carolscookies.com

 

Sweet Shot Cookies

Sweet Shot Cookies specializes in infused cookies and cookie cakes. Their homemade gooey-infused cookies can be filled with anything from marshmallow fluff to dark chocolate ganache—you name it, they infuse it. They can be ordered pre-filled or if you’re a DIY’er, they can be delivered with a syringe of flavor so you can inject it yourself with as much filling as you’d like. Now, that is our kind of DIY!

3211 W. Armitage, Logan Square; Online: sweetshotcookies.com

 

Insomnia

Got a chocolate chip cookie pregnancy crave? Up at all hours tending to a newbie in the house? Insomnia has you covered. Most of their locations deliver until 1 a.m. so you can indulge your sweet tooth. 

Locations in & near the city; Online: insomniacookies.com

 

Defloured

Defloured makes their chocolate chip cookies so mouth-wateringly amazing that you’d never know it’s gluten-free. In fact, their entire menu is gluten-free. That’s right, we didn’t forget about the folks who steer clear of gluten, but want a cookie that isn’t dry for once!

1477 W. Balmoral, Andersonville; Online: deflouredbakery.com

— Maria Chambers & Matt Kirouac

Featured photo: Gustavo Fring via Pexels

RELATED STORIES:

25 Telltale Signs You’re a Proud Chicago Mom

Welcome to our Tinybeans family!
Be sure to check your email for new activities, recipes and parenting hacks – and to see if you’ve won!

 

 

 

 

 

 

FALL FOR TINYBEANS!

Enter to Win a $250 Gift Card!

Enter your email and zip code below for a chance to win a Mastercard Gift Card. We’ll pick one winner per month through October 31, 2022 – 7 lucky winners in all!

I agree to the official rules and to receive email communications from Tinybeans. By providing my email address, I agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.