Second to None: NYC’s Best Kids’ Consignment Shops

Trending Now


Whether you’re in the market for some fun back to school fashions that won’t break the bank, or you’ve got some gently (or never) worn clothes the kids have outgrown, your next stop should be one of NYC’s fine consignment shops. Get cash for those like-new pieces and pick up a few items for well below retail. Here’s where to head to stretch that dollar!

photo: via Flying Squirrel Facebook page

In Greenpoint, Brooklyn: Flying Squirrel

The vibe:
Organized, inviting, and the go-to neighborhood spot for in-the-know mamas

What they accept: In this airy, open shop, new clothes are sold in front, while items on consignment can be found in the back of the store and online. Donated clothing for kids must be clean and in excellent condition — no missing buttons or stains at all, especially for items for kids under 24 months of age. The store’s most popular premium brands are Splendid, Mini Rodini, Bobo Choses and some Gap and H&M items may be considered.

How it works: 50/50 split between the store and seller; a price is negotiated between the shop and seller based on the brand, and if it can sell for $20 or greater. Payment is available in the form of a check or store credit.

How to drop off items: Drop off times are Mon. – Thurs., 10:30 a.m. to 1 p.m., or by appointment.

Need to know: Items move fast here. (You might say they “fly” out the door…) So if an item on consignment item catches your eye, jump on it —  it might not be there next week. (Follow the store on Instagram to get a peek at the latest, cutest goods.)

87 Oak St.
Hours: Mon. – Sun., 10 a.m. – 7 p.m.

photo: via Jane’s Exchange Facebook page

In the East Village: Jane’s Exchange

The vibe: Bargain-oriented customers young and old set the tone in this whimsical shop

What they accept: Children’s clothing (infant to size 12), children’s furniture and accessories (baby carriers, car seats in mint condition no more than five years old, etc.), games, toys, books, DVDs, portable cribs, highchairs, swings, excersaucers, maternity and nursing clothing, and other parenting goods.  No more than 20 items per drop off will be accepted. Clothing must be in good condition, and is bought by season. Check out the list of baby gear they are looking for before dropping off items, and be sure to call the store before dropping off large pieces.

How it works: Consignors receive 30% of the sale price of all items under $100.00 and 40% for items $100.00 and over. Money earned must be used as credit to buy other consigned items at Jane’s Exchange.

How to drop off items: You’ll need to make an appointment by calling, emailing, or stopping by the store.

Need to know: The consignment period is 60 days. After this period, you’ll need to collect unsold clothing or it will becomes the property of Jane’s Exchange.

191 East 3rd St.
East Village
Phone: 212-677-0380
Hours: Mon – Fri.,10 a.m. – 6 p.m., Sat. – Sun., noon – 6p.m.

photo: Clementine Consignment 

In Greenwich Village: Clementine Consignment

The vibe: Cheerful and inviting downtown bargain spot

How it works: You receive 40% of the final sale price of the items you consign. Checks are distributed quarterly, but sellers can pick up the balance owed to them at any time in the store; payment in the form of store credit is also available. Clementine prices its merchandise at a 50-80% discount from current retail prices, with costs varying based on the condition of each item. Prices are lowered at season’s end.

What they accept: Designer maternity, infant and toddler clothing up to children’s size eight. Make sure to check out the list of brands and clothing types that they don’t accept before taking in clothes. Clementine Consignment also accepts hats, diaper bags, booties and new or almost-new shoes; it doesn’t accept toys or gear.

How to drop off items: You can drop off consignments at any time during store hours. Sellers can read and sign the store’s consignment agreement online. Consignment by mail is also an option.

Need to know:  The store accepts items for all seasons at any time. Your consignment period will begin the day your merchandise is put out for sale. If an item hasn’t sold after 60 days, the consignor has the choice to either pick it back up, or have the shop donate the item to Room to Grow.

39 1/2 Washington Square S.
Greenwich Village
Phone: 212-228-9333
Hours: Mon. – Sat., 11 a.m. – 7 p.m., Sun.: 11 a.m. – 5 p.m.

photo: via Wyatt Lily Facebook page

In Westchester:
Wyatt Lily

The vibe: Hip, trendy and fairly high-end transplant from the Upper West Side in Westchester. (For years Wyatt Lily served Manhattan on Columbus Ave. You’ll now find it’s chic new and used fashions in Scarsdale — but they do ship!)

What they accept: This boutique includes a small consignment section that is stocked with high-end attire. Wyatt Lily accepts unused and lightly-worn items for boys and girls sizes zero to six years of age. The store considers the following brands for consignment: Oscar de la Renta, Burberry, Milly Minis, Chloe, Moncler, Fleurisse, La Miniatura, Dolce & Gabbana, Gucci, Hermes Little, Marc Jacobs, Stella McCartney and many others.

How it works:  40% of the item’s sale price goes to the customer.

Dropping off: Drop off times are Mon. – Fri, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.

Need to know: Anything not sold after two months is donated to a worthwhile children’s charity such as The Salvation Army, or you can choose to pick it up.

1 Chase Rd.
Scarsdale, Ny
Hours: Mon. – Sat., 10 a.m. – 7 p.m., Sun., 11 a.m. – 7 p.m.


Where do you go for new-to-you kid’s clothes? Tell us in the comments below!

— Rachel Sokol

Welcome to our Tinybeans family!
Be sure to check your email for new activities, recipes and parenting hacks – and to see if you’ve won!








Enter to Win a $250 Gift Card!

Enter your email and zip code below for a chance to win a Mastercard Gift Card. We’ll pick one winner per month through August 31, 2022 – 5 lucky winners in all!

I agree to the official rules and to receive email communications from Tinybeans. By providing my email address, I agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.